The Gator is a foul beast that engages its victims in a fit of blowjobedness, and after giving enough head to get the victim going it stops before the victim can climax. She never fini...
The story of Gator was explained in Episode 16 (around the 38 minute mark), however the encounter was alluded to even before the podcast existed, and was indirectly referenced a few times on earlier podcasts.
After the release of this video, it is suspected that Gator is actually Taylor Swift. There is evidence to support this, as Taylor Swift has a song and an album called Red, possibly about her former lover and she owned a house in Cape Cod, where he lives.